« American Public Media library survey | Main | Text a Librarian »
September 29, 2008
hakia: semantic search (you mean experts' opinions count?)
Yes, yes, it's been in all the news, I know. But I still don't know how I feel about hakia, the new search engine designed to "unlock the credible and free resources on the Web for all users." This semantic search technology gives higher ranking to those resources recommended by professional groups with different areas of expertise. To get an idea of what search results look like, here are the results for a search on "Marfan Syndrome." Note the top few and the little pop-up info on the right when you hover over the results.
The company invited librarians to suggest URLs that we "as information experts, believe lead to the most credible websites for any given topic." To me this is really Librarians' Internet Index turned into a search engine. I'm curious to see how the market takes to this, beyond librarians and teachers. If the regular-old-person won't use it, it won't make it. You can read more details on the hakia site if you're interested in learning more.
September 29, 2008 | Permalink
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c511253ef010534df214b970b
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference hakia: semantic search (you mean experts' opinions count?):
Comments
I don't like the idea at all. Google pays its quality raters for rating the quality of its websites. Yahoo pays its inhouse technology analysts to rate websites.
They are asking a person to give a service for free. In other words is it free for you to provide peer reviewed sources of information to a private company.
You would be providing a free source of information that they would then turn around and sell to someone else.
The approach is predatory in nature. Unless they can offer some better recognition, or other form of compensation, it is not something I would do.
Posted by: Book Calendar | October 6, 2008
I like the idea, assuming that Hakia can successfully crowdsource the content from their target providers- info professionals and librarians. it seems unlikely though. There still might be some support issues though- I tried to install their search widget on my e-resources page and still haven't had any luck. Of course, what I know about Java you could write on the back of a stamp.
Posted by: richard james | October 1, 2008







