« Using Jott to save time | Main | survey on libraries and search engines/gigantic websites »
January 02, 2008
Pew Study on Information-Finding Behavior
Three days ago, Pew released a new study: Information Searches that Solve Problems: How people use the internet, libraries, and government agencies when they need help. The study is available as a 42 PDF.
The big news is that it shows that Generation Y (people aged 18-29) visits the library more than any other age group. The below statistics also show that library use steadily declines as people age--what can we do about that? Are we neglecting our senior populations once more? Is there an opportunity for added outreach here?
- Generation Y (18-30): 62%
- Generation X (31-42): 59%
- Trailing Baby Boomers(43-52): 57%
- Leading Baby Boomers (53-61): 46%
- Matures (62-71): 42%
- After Work (72+): 32%
People were asked to think about their latest information-seeking episode that fit within the scope of the 10 areas pre-defined by the survey (all of which had potential ties to government agencies), and report where they went for help. People could choose more than one answer. The results? Bad for libraries--showing that we are most certainly not in the public's consciousness as an information-finding resources.
- 58%: the internet (at home, work, a public library or some other place)
- 53%: professionals such as doctors, lawyers or financial experts
- 45%: friends and family members
- 36%: newspapers and magazines.
- 34%: government office or agency
- 16%: television and radio.
- 13%: the public library
Come on people. The television beat us! Someone would rather turn to CNN than the public library for information on Medicare options, local schools, or finding a new job. What does that tell us? I know that libraries do a lot more than provide access to government information, but it is disappointing to see that we fall so very short of our goals of information for all.
I hope that this survey will get public libraries thinking about new ways to get the word out to the public that they provide reference services, offer help finding government (and other) information, and are experts on local resources and agencies. One suggestion would be to start a Book-A-Librarian service--an advertised service where users can make half-hour or hour-long appointments with librarians on staff to get detailed one-on-one research help (without the stress of having to get to the others next in line at the desk).
Two small rays of happiness for libraries though:
- If people did go to the library for help, 64% of them found the outcome successful. I'm sure we'd like to see a higher number, but that's nothing to sneeze at.
- Reference isn't dead! 58% of those who turned to the public library with their needs said they used library reference books to get their answers. Now whether or not they found those on their own or were guided to them by a librarian, it doesn't matter. They found and successfully used reference books to help them get information. It's not time to weed that reference collection into oblivion just yet, my friends!
Other interesting findings include:
- 53% of U.S. adults surveyed said they visited a library in the last year
- Internet users are twice as likely to visit the library as non-Internet users
- 2/3 of library visitors used computers in the library
- 62% of those who used computers viewed library resources, including the catalog, and 65% looked up information on the web
- education-related tasks and problems are what draw people to the public library the most
- the digital divide is having a huge impact on information-finding skills and access
There has already been quiet a flurry of discussion on PubLib and other listservs/Twitter/Facebook/blogs, with a large number of library staff questioning and outright scoffing at the findings that Gen Y citizens use the library more than other age groups. Given the expanse of that generation--18-29--I have no problem believing the results. I think it stems from people's misunderstanding of who GenY is. We're not talking teenagers! Let's think about this--what group has children who need public library resources for school, or storybooks for bedtime? Young people in Gen Y (and also Gen X). To me, that explains at least part of that result--and I would be interested to see if that number has changed over time...if more people in that age group go to the library now than did 20 years ago.
If you want to get a good summary, you can read one of the many articles published about the study, including one from Reuters or one from
my library's local paper, the San Jose Mercury News.
January 2, 2008 | Permalink
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c511253ef00e5505218e98833
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Pew Study on Information-Finding Behavior:
Comments
This is one of the best posts I've seen regarding the study. There has been a large amount of misinterpretation of the findings, including an Associated Press article on the survey which appeared in many places, including CNN.com and the Chicago Tribune.
One thing to keep in mind about the findings. Assuming that 18-30 year olds have a higher propensity to use the library, it doesn't mean they use it frequently. They might, but we don't know that from the survey. It only asked people if they visited a library in the past year, and did not inquire how many times they visited the library. It's possible, for example, there are many light users in this group who only stop in occasionally.
Unfortunately, the survey also doesn't tell us why people visit the library - what services they use when they come. The survey focused on resources people use when seeking information to solve a problem. Based on many community and patron surveys I've conducted for public libraries Gen Y uses the library very differently than "Leading Boomers" or "Matures."
For planning, libraries should collect solid, quantitative data on who uses the library, how often they use it and what services they use.
Posted by: defconsult | January16, 2008
I have written a blog post discussing this Pew study and your comments about senior populations at
http://seniorfriendlylibraries.blogspot.com/2008/01/recent-pew-study-of-information.html
Posted by: Isabelle Fetherston | January13, 2008
You can Book-A-Librarian at Northamptonshire Libraries in the UK - see http://www.northamptonshire.gov.uk/Leisure/Libraries/Learning/pka.htm for details!
Posted by: Sarah Washford | January 6, 2008
A group of librarians taking a pro-active approach to increasing awareness is"Slam the Boards"! On the 10th of every month, we log on to Yahoo Answers, Wikianswers, etc and answer as many questions as we can, always taking care to cite sources and to stress that we are librarians. Many of us have had answers picked as "Best answer" or been listed as "favorite sources"
The first Slam the Boards date of 2008 is Thursday, January 10. This is a great way to promote the visibility of library reference services!
Visit http://answerboards.wetpaint.com/page/Slam+the+Boards%21 for details. Pick up as many questions as you reasonably can on the 10th (and try to pick up a few now and then in-between slam dates).
Care to contribute at a deeper level? There's a special QuestionPoint account set up where we can archive links to our answers (whether they were chosen "best" or not) so that researchers can potentially look at how librarians interact with the answer board world. Contact me for login info and entry details.
For those who care to get social about their participation (or who just want to be reminded that there's someone else out there doing this), there's a Meebo chat room available at: http://answerboards.wetpaint.com/page/Chat+and+Networking (if you use meebo, you can add it to your account as "Board Slammin' Librarians.")
Want some serious props from Yahoo? Participating librarians can be designated YA "Knowledge Partners." Contact Bill Pardue at Arlington heights Memorial Library for details. bpardue@ahml.info
Posted by: Lesley Williams | January 4, 2008







