« Customize Office 2007 a big | Main | Improve ALA Wiki »

June 28, 2007

eBooks not known and not liked

Library Journal's Academic Newswire released the following story earlier this month: "Ebooks Gain at Libraries, but Lack of Awareness Remains an Issue."  It focuses on eBooks in academic settings, but could be of interest to all libraries.  They discuss a survey by eBrary that found that 88% of libraries subscribed to eBooks of some sort.  But....here's our problem:

Only six percent of respondents said ebook usage was excellent, compared to 22 percent who said usage was poor.

Right.  I don't think it's just lack of awareness, which clearly has an impact too.  I think it's a lack of good interfaces, the behemoth of digital rights management which makes downloading books a total pain.  If you had to fiddle, download licenses, update programs, install some software--all just to get a book on your PDA...would you come back?  And yes, I know...the first time is worse because you're updating and installing stuff which you won't have to do in that quantity again.  But that doesn't matter.  If the first time is bad, the second time isn't coming.  People won't come back...and clearly, this survey shows that they don't.

What can we do?  We need to get good information out about our eBooks to our entire communities.  We need to lobby for an end to DRM.  We need to lobby for better interfaces and processes from the eBooks vendors.  We need to assess whether the use of these resources really warrants their presence.  Everything in libraries is about the most bang you can get for your buck.  eBooks aren't any different.

June 28, 2007 | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/t/trackback/12541/19674702

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference eBooks not known and not liked:

Comments

I agree totally with you. When working in an academic library a couple of years ago now I lost count of the number of calls I'd get about our patrons not being able to access ebooks. The conversation would go something like this:

Me -> Have you downloaded the plugin?
Patron -> What plugin?
Me -> There is a link on the main access page
Patron -> But I clicked on a link in the catalogue
Me -> Ok go here.... and click this link
Patron -> I did that and nothing happened

At this point three things happened.

- They were at work and so couldn't install the Windows / Mac plugin (insufficient privileges)
- They were at home and were using an unsupported browser, or were on dialup and couldn't wait for the multi megabyte download
- They were on campus and couldn't install the plugin (insufficient privileges)

Either way the usage of the ebook collection wasn't as good as it could have been. Why? Because of DRM.

I thought of this again when I read this post by CW, http://blog.flexnib.com/2007/06/22/dark-age/, how much information are we losing because it is locked behind proprietary DRM that won't be accessible to future generations? A sobering thought.

Posted by: techxploer | June28, 2007

Amen! Libraries should be exerting more pressure on the vendors to offer a product that is actually usable. As long as we keep paying and accepting the product as is, why would they change?

Posted by: Michele Mizejewski | June29, 2007

You may recall a few years ago a scheme that tried to get people to buy DVDs which ceased to work after a certain period of time after the first play. Needless to say, no one was interested in purchasing such a product.

But... if no physical media is involved, and if it was a "rental" such as with libraries... it would be a considerably simpler model of DRM for people to deal with. People would "check out" the item by downloading it, be able to use it for whatever the length of the check-out period is, and then it would cease to work. Do they need it longer? Then they can check it out again.

The major objections (aside from having to have any kind of DRM at all, of course! :-) would be that enforcing the DRM would require some sort of player program embedded with the content, and re-downloading the content for an additional check-out could be a pain.

But compared to what people have to go through now to get an e-book to work....

Posted by: Scott | June29, 2007

Post a comment

*Please only submit your comment once. Comments are moderated due to spam problems. I have to approve the comment before it will show up. I will try to do it quickly.*
LiB's simple ground rules for comments:
1. No personal attacks, rude, or intolerant comments.
2. Comments need to actually relate to the blog post topic.