« PLA 2006: You’ve Got What It Takes!: Peer Training in Your Library | Main | PLA 2006: Empowering Library Staff to Meet the Technology Needs of Spanish Speakers »

March 24, 2006

Beware Ego Centric Conference Sessions

Excuse the following rant, but I have to get this off my chest.  I have been to too many conference sessions guilty of ego centricity and I'm losing my mind.

<rant>
The thing that annoys me the most at conferences is not PowerPoint slides, or people reading directly from their notes, or people's cell phones going off...it's presenters who stand up and talk to you for an hour about the minutiae of what happened at their library during a certain project, talking in great excruciating detail about how their library "did it" including each administrative step, what specific challenges they faced from their administrators/boards/patrons/staff, and really giving you nothing to take away that is useful. 

No practical tips, no how-to steps, no thought provoking ideas, just an hour-long verbalized quarterly report.  Because that's what it sounds like.  I don't care if your director was pregnant during your ILS conversion and how that impacted your workload.  I don't care if your library employs 37 librarians and 88 paraprofessionals, then broken out by staff classification.  I don't care if your building's toilet leaks.  I don't care to hear the minute details of your specific situation. 

I come to conferences to learn about what I can do for my own library...to get real "take aways."  I want practical handouts, not your PowerPoint slides.  I want you to spark some ideas in me.  I want you to make me think.  Design a presentation with the thought: what things would someone need to know if he or she was going to do something similar?  What are all the things to think about?  What are some of the places to find more information about this?  What are some of the resources I found most useful?  I don't come to learn about the ins and outs of your library: I come to learn how to help mine.
</rant>

March 24, 2006 | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c511253ef00e55051fd328833

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Beware Ego Centric Conference Sessions:

» Librarians to presenters: don't bury the lede! from See Also
Two posts on presentations at Cil2006 reminded me of one my pet peeves when watching conference presentations: presenters who don't "get to the good stuff" right up front. First, Sarah Houghton at Librarian in Black warns us to Beware... [Read More]

Tracked on Mar 25, 2006 3:14:05 PM

» Carnival of the Infosciences #30 from Open Stacks
Step right up and prepare for the mind-altering experience that is the Carnival of the Infosciences #30. This week we celebrate the cross-scheduling of conferences and the bipolar distribution of librarian mindpower. But first, a few submissions. Amand... [Read More]

Tracked on Mar 26, 2006 8:35:23 PM

» Carnival of the Infosciences #30 from Open Stacks
Step right up and prepare for the mind-altering experience that is the Carnival of the Infosciences #30. This week we celebrate the cross-scheduling of conferences and the bipolar distribution of librarian mindpower. But first, a few submissions. Amand... [Read More]

Tracked on Mar 27, 2006 9:21:52 AM

Comments

Thank you for this! I am guilty of having participated in some of these presentations (my only defense is that my objections were overruled by the more experienced librarians in the group). I am so tired of this model.

Posted by: Kate Kluttz | March30, 2006

I'm glad you enjoyed our session Paul! We tried very hard to give people the tools they'd need to do a project like this--not drone on and on about our own specific situation.

Posted by: Sarah Houghton (LiB) | March27, 2006

Karen, I intentionally avoided most tech programs for that reason. I knew I'd be bored. PLA and other general library conferences are places for techies to come share information about tech--not learn about tech. I went to sessions on Spanish-language services, teen services, training, etc. I only attended two tech sessions (yours on LII & Michael's/Jenny's on RSS & blogs). And I actually learned one or two things at each, so I was happy. CIL is definitely on the agenda for next year, but my beef about ego-centricity is really about all different types of presenters.

Posted by: Sarah Houghton (LiB) | March27, 2006

And here I was thinking I was the only one cranky about this subject. Oddly enough, I missed the first 15 minutes of your presentation on digital archives because I'd heard as much drivel in a table-talk as I could stand. I'm glad I left when I did. Your presentation was jam packed and fun filled so I'm here trying to fill in the first part of it from your ppt slides. Thanks for a great talk. It gave me a lot of ideas for my own project in Brunswick, ME.

Posted by: Paul Dostie | March26, 2006

Sarah, I strongly encourage you to attend CIL and similar technology conferences. PLA's technology track isn't beefy enough for you. I'm sorry I missed Lee Rainey, but aside from that, my $250 conference fee only allowed me to give a talk to PLA.

As for presenters, yeah, you got it.

Posted by: K.G. Schneider | March26, 2006

Still, a big part of me wishes I had gone to CIL instead of PLA. PLA is a place for experts in their field to present information to others who are non-experts, while conferences like CIL & Internet Librarian, being more specialized, are a place for experts in one particular field to share with each other.

Posted by: Sarah Houghton (LiB) | March25, 2006

Sarah, I said much the same thing about presenters at CIL/ISE2006!

Posted by: Lazygal | March25, 2006

Well someone had to say it! Hurrah!!

Posted by: Heather Acton | March24, 2006

I feel your pain. I've been to some great presentations, but sometimes when I go to a conference it seems totally random if I'm going to end up at a useful session or not. I've ended up in sessions where someone has spent the whole time detailing their specific organizational culture, when I just wanted some practical tips about setting up a new library service.

Posted by: tangognat | March24, 2006

Post a comment

*Please only submit your comment once. Comments are moderated due to spam problems. I have to approve the comment before it will show up. I will try to do it quickly.*
LiB's simple ground rules for comments:
1. No personal attacks, rude, or intolerant comments.
2. Comments need to actually relate to the blog post topic.